Shandy Rachel Garrison v. Estate of Eugene Phillips

Thomas G. Nance (Charlotte, NC) (Automobile Liability) obtained a defense verdict in Shandy Rachel Garrison v. Estate of Eugene Phillips. The case involved a minor motor vehicle accident in 2008, from which Plaintiff claimed chronic, permanent injuries to her neck, back, elbow and migraines. Plaintiff applied for Social Security disability 1 year after the accident and was declared totally disabled. The Defendant admitted negligence but denied that Plaintiff suffered any injury. The Defendant passed away in 2014, and his adult daughters attended the trial in his place. At trial, Plaintiff sought in excess of $140,000 for incurred damages and unspecified damages for future medical treatment, loss of income, pain and suffering and permanent impairment. Following a 4 day trial, the jury deliberated 40 minutes before returning a defense verdict.